The ever confusing Trust and Will no-contest clause is continually being used and abused in California Trust and Will lawsuits. The irony is that a beneficiary is rarely, if ever, disinherited under a no-contest clause any more because the law is favorably skewed to prevent forfeiture. In other words, no-contest clauses simply do not apply except in the most extreme cases (and your case is not extreme no matter what you think). Not only must you meet the requirements of the Probate Code for a no-contest clause to apply, you must also be acting without probable cause—a nearly impossible standard to meet. If you don’t meet the standard, then you are not in danger of being disinherited regardless of the legal action you file.
But what about a bad Trustee, can he be disinherited under a no-contest clause if he breaches his duties as Trustee? The short answer is no, but why not?
The first rule of no-contest clauses is that you must undertake an action that is specifically listed in the no-contest clause as being a triggering event. More than that, Probate Code section 21310 specifically limits the actions a no-contest clause can affect. Actions that can be used to trigger a no-contest clause are limited to: (1) direct contests of a document (meaning you are trying to overturn a Trust, Will, or Trust or Will amendment), (2) creditors’ claims, and (3) challenging the characterization of property as being either community or separate. Further, a no-contest clause will not apply where someone acts with probable cause of success.
Notice how there is no mention of disinheritance for a bad Trustee? That’s because there no basis to disinherit a bad Trustee just for breaching a duty to the Trust. In fact, I have never seen a no-contest clause that includes a provision that triggers disinheritance if a Trustee/beneficiary breaches his duties as Trustee. But even if a Trust or Will no-contest clause had such a provision, it would be unenforceable because only the items outlined in the code can be enforced for no-contest clause purposes.
So that means a bad Trustee who is also a beneficiary will not be disinherited due to his bad actions as Trustee. But the Trustee is not off the hook for engaging in breaches of Trust. The Trustee can still be held liable for any damage that is caused as a result of a breach of Trust, and those damages can be taken out from the bad Trustee’s share of the Trust estate. Unfortunately, that only occurs when a court orders it. That means the burden is on you to file your lawsuit, prove your case at trial, and get your order surcharging the Trustee for damages.